Gemini Fails to Deliver on Google Assistant's Promises for Pixel 9 Users

Overview

Google is replacing its long-standing voice assistant, Google Assistant, with a new system named Gemini on its Pixel 9 devices.

Comparative Functionality

While Gemini aims to utilize large language models for more conversational interactions, it fails to perform many basic tasks essential for daily use.

Major Shortcomings of Gemini

• Local results are less effective: Queries about local business hours return minimal context without helpful links.
• Failure to take notes: Users can no longer dictate notes, a major loss in productivity features.
• To-do lists unsupported: Unlike Assistant, Gemini cannot facilitate to-do list management extensively.
• Inaccurate weather forecasts: Users report location errors in weather data, which frustrates those seeking timely updates.
• No instant navigation: Directions requests do not launch immediate navigation, causing delays in user experience.
• Limited music service integration: Gemini restricts music playback to YouTube Music only.
• No direct links to streaming: Users must manually locate content instead of being directed automatically.
• Photo search capability lost: Requests for specific images in Google Photos are unsupported.
• Loss of news briefing: The daily news feature is effectively removed, replacing it with unhelpful guidance.
• Missing routine automation: Many of the smart home commands and automations have been rendered ineffective.
• Slower response times: Gemini's responses lag behind those of Assistant, diminishing user experience quality.

Conclusion

While Gemini represents Google’s ambition for a more advanced AI assistant, it currently falls short of basic usability and function compared to its predecessor. Users may wish to continue using Google Assistant, which is still available amidst the platform's evolution.