Health Concerns: Critique of Elle Macpherson's Approach to Cancer Treatment

Health Concerns in Cancer Treatment

Elle Macpherson, once celebrated as "The Body," has sparked significant health concerns following her criticisms of modern medicine in favor of alternative therapies. As a breast cancer oncologist, I understand the complexities of breast cancer treatment.

Understanding DCIS and Treatment Options

Macpherson was diagnosed with oestrogen receptor positive, HER2 positive intraductal carcinoma (DCIS). This type of cancer typically does not metastasize. Treatment generally involves surgical intervention to remove the DCIS. However, recurrence risks remain, influenced by various factors such as age and margins.

• Age at Diagnosis: Key in assessing recurrence probabilities.
• Surgical Margins: Close margins elevate recurrence risks.
• Complementary Therapies: Can be beneficial alongside conventional treatments.

Clinical Trials: The Backbone of Evidence-Based Treatment

At the Breast Cancer Research Centre of WA, we conduct international clinical trials, assessing the safety and efficacy of new therapies through a rigorous phase system. This ensures that we only recommend scientifically validated treatments.

• Phase One: Safety and dosage in small groups.
• Phase Two: Effectiveness evaluated in larger cohorts.
• Phase Three: Comparison against standard treatments with large population samples.

The Dangers of Alternative Treatments

While Macpherson has not experienced a recurrence, promoting alternative, untested therapies is a serious issue. Such actions may mislead countless women navigating breast cancer treatment options and undermine the foundation of evidence-based medicine.

Informed Decision Making in Oncology

Every patient deserves the right to make informed decisions about their treatment. Oncologists advocate for evidence-based practices to ensure the best outcomes for patients. It's crucial to balance personal choice with scientifically validated treatment methods.